Customer Attrition vs Customer Retention


This article will examine customer attrition statistics and how to decrease it while increasing the likelihood of more referrals and online 5-star reviews.

customer attrition

What is Customer Attrition?


Customer attrition, often called customer churn or turnover, is the rate at which customers don’t refer more customers, give you an online review, or ask for additional services. They are the “one and done” customers, and while they help pay for payroll and keep the lights on, it can kill the overall profitability of your business.  Don’t hit the wall with your hammer just yet; let’s dig into why customer attrition occurs at higher rates and how to combat each reason for loss.


The Cost of Customer Acquisition vs Retention


Customer acquisition cost (CAC) and customer retention cost (CRC) are important business growth metrics. Did you know that gaining a new customer costs five times more than retaining them or getting referrals?

customer attrition

How to Decrease Customer Attrition


Customers may only leave a Google review, refer a neighbor or friend, or call you back for more work if you meet all the criteria for home improvement excellence. 


Improve Your Initial Assessments

Never upsell to make an extra $100 or even $1,000 on a client. Just give them what they need. A referral and online review can make you $15,000 to $100,000 in the long run. Only some jobs are going to be $10k to $50k. You need to make money but do it so well that your entire process is such a fantastic experience that it turns into years of additional work. 


Improve Your Branding

Do you want to be known as the Amazon of your industry or just the guys you won the bid? Step up your branding and professionalism with uniforms, wrapped vehicles, and yard signs. 


Uniforms Lead to Lower Customer Attrition

Many contractors wear different clothing styles—that’s an epic fail! With 61% of customers stating that uniforms make your company's appeal more credible, don’t think about uniforms; use them. 


Vehicle Wrapping Leads to Lower Customer Attrition

Vehicle wrapping, known as “mobile billboards,” can cost you $2,000 to $5,000 per vehicle, but it’s worth every penny. It tells the customer you are “all in” on this business. Who would you instead do your roof, gutters, HVAC, or plumbing… the wrapped vehicle fleet or the guy who shows up in a 1995 Ford Ranger?


Yard Signs Lead to Lower Customer Attrition

When a customer allows you to place a business yard sign while you’re doing work or possibly for the following week for a slight discount, you get free local advertising to their neighbors. This is a sign your initial assessment, pricing, and customer service are on point. Mark down these types of customers with high potential for referrals and online reviews in your Home Services CRM. 


Your Pricing

Never be the lowest pricing on the market, but never be more than 10% higher than the highest company. Ya, it’s 2024-2025, and there’s inflation, and people are counting every penny. Still, in pricing psychology, higher pricing is always more lucrative and gets the consumer to ask what you must do differently to charge more. Besides, you want bigger payouts and can only get bigger payouts by charging more. 


Eco-Friendly Tax Credits and Public Relations

You may not care about recycling or global warming, but some people do. Simply find a way to safely repurpose your customer’s bad wood, gutters, etc Many local artists would love to have access to these materials. 


You can also consider melting down or repurposing them with some kind of investment. The IRS may even give you a tax credit. For example, Virginia has a tax credit for repurposing materials within the scope of your business. Ask your CPA or whoever does your taxes and get write-offs and more eco-friendly customers at the same time. 


If you do have something like this in place, put it on your website and in your marketing too!


Keep the Language and Music Clean

Many contractors will play music which is fine, but this isn’t a high school rager. Keep the music clean and your language with it. While the homeowner or business may not care, the neighbors may and those complaints to your customer won’t bid well for an online review, referral, or customer retention and reduced customer attrition. 


Clean Up as You Go

Home Improvement is dirty, but what if you have to stop work right now? Will the home look like a disaster? What about people stepping on nails? Ensure your customer's happiness throughout the project and avoid liability for on-site injuries simultaneously. 

A great home improvement team has demolition and/or removal teams, clean teams, and installation teams. It’s like Henry Ford came to your company and showed you how to run the Assembly line in terms of people and efficiency. 


Customers see this level of planning and specialization, and they don’t want their home to look like a warzone ever, so clean up as you go along. 


Entire Site Cleaning, then the Walkthrough

Every contractor knows you have to do a final walkthrough, but with a finely detailed cleaning of every nook and cranny, the homeowner realizes you are leaving their home cleaner than when you arrived. 


Customer Satisfaction Follow-Ups

Call every customer 3 months after your service, then every 6 months until you or they die, lol. Ask them how their roof, plumbing, HVAC, or gutters are. This consistent follow-up will be the difference no other company does. Never ask for more work as a premise for the call, just see how they are doing and if they are super happy then ask them for a referral or review.

How much is a 5-Star Google Review worth in 2024-2025


Customers may only leave a Google review and/or refer a neighbor or friend if you cross all the boxes of home improvement excellence. 

Our agency customers state that because the number of reviews, their score, and the reviews are front and center on their Google Business Profile and Website’s home page, every 5-star Google Review they get that has a comment is worth at least $1,500.00 per month. Many other marketing articles agree with this evaluation (proof).

Need Help with your local marketing?

Need Help?

Book a FREE Consult


Our Promise.  No pushy sales. Just a friendly discussion about you, your company, struggles, needs, goals, timelines, and we offer FREE and paid solutions. At the very least you get more knowledge.

company credit cards
By Will Schmidt January 21, 2025
Learn when and how to start issuing local business credit cards to employees.
A 3d rendering of a cell phone with the word tiktok ban on it.
By Will Schmidt January 17, 2025
How will the TikTok ban impact local service companies? What is the ban? What will happen? What should you do next for social media marketing?
door knocking,door knocking guide,door knocking guide 2025
By Will Schmidt January 15, 2025
Unlock the secrets to effective door-knocking with our ultimate guide! Learn proven strategies to win residential customers, from crafting branded flyers and perfecting your pitch to overcoming objections and tracking results. Master the art of building trust and making lasting impressions for your home improvement business. Start converting doors into opportunities today!
home services conferences
By Will Schmidt January 14, 2025
Learn why local festivals and sponsorships are better than industry conferences and conventions. The information also provides suggestions for using that budget for employee benefits and motivational initiatives for higher retention.
emergency service leads,disaster leads for businesses
By Will Schmidt January 14, 2025
How to gain more emergency home services leads during disasters without looking like an ambulance chaser or desperate.
storytelling marketing,power of storytelling
By Will Schmidt December 23, 2024
Learn how storytelling can improve your local leads, branding, visibility, and conversions.
uniform guide for local businesses,do uniforms grow sales
By Will Schmidt December 23, 2024
Learn how uniforms can help you grow referrals, reviews, and team unity in this short 5-minute read.
impact of uniforms on local businesses
By Will Schmidt December 23, 2024
This free guide tells how Facebook reviews help grow your local service business. Enjoy!
skilled labor hr guide,small business hr guide,small business compensation
By Will Schmidt December 21, 2024
FREE download. Learn how to pay your local labor force; salaries, benefits, health insurance, dental, vision, bonus structures. Everything you need in one article! Read it now.
home page content,home page design
By Will Schmidt December 20, 2024
How to build the perfect home page for your local business to rank faster, convert visitors, and keep your branding in tact.
Show More